BestCreditCard Home
BestCreditCard Home
BBB
Only BestCreditCard Finds the Best Card
Based on How You Spend.

How to Pick Between Two Credit Cards

Picking between two similar credit cards comes down to the numbers.
Rishil
Rishil Pansuria

June 1, 2020

Credit Cards
See Best Credit Cards by Category:
All content is written by editorial staff or writers engaged by the site, not by marketers/sales staff. Editors responsible for producing the content are not in contact or affiliated with any advertiser and are not compensated based on success of the affiliate links. All decisions regarding recommendations are determined separately from advertising relationships. Any opinions, analyses, reviews or recommendations expressed are those of the author's alone, and have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any card issuer.

This Offer Is Not Available

This offer is not currently available on BestCreditCard. Please take a look at similar offers!

With the variety of different credit card options out there, it can get quite confusing at times which cards are even worth applying for. In our opinion, we believe the best credit card for you largely depends on both your past and future spending habits, any upcoming expenses, and how you plan to use the credit card. For example, if you’re looking to do a ton of holiday shopping in the next few months, it makes a lot more sense to go for a cash back or rewards credit card rather than a secured credit card. Below, we have gone over some of the common factors that help you easily differentiate two credit cards.

Common Differentiators

A factor that can easily help you differentiate two credit cards is its annual fee. This is one of the most important numbers to consider when deciding between credit cards. If an annual hundred dollar fee is too much for your bank account, it’s much wiser to go with the card with a lower or zero annual fee. Similarly, if you don’t think you can pay off your bill every month, the card with a lower purchase APR is a better investment. Nowadays, many credit cards offer an introductory discounted annual fee and APR for the first year.

It’s also common with higher tier credit cards to offer a welcome bonus as well. Some cards allow you to redeem this welcome bonus for cash or other rewards. For example, the Chase Sapphire Preferred card offers 60,000 points after you spend $4,000 within the first 3 months.

Annual fees, APR, and bonuses are some of the more well-known numbers to look at when picking between two credit cards. It’s important to note that most beginner cards won’t have any annual fees or bonuses, and APR usually depends on your credit score.

If you’re comparing two cash back or rewards credit cards, it’s important to look at more than just the general rewards rate. The more flexible the rate is, the more places you can use the card to earn points or cash back. For example, a card that only offers 5% cash back on dining may sound good on paper, but is severely limiting where you can earn cash back. A better card would be one that offers 3% cash back on dining, 2% on gas, and 1% everywhere else. The more places the card allows you to earn points or cash back, the easier it is to rack up rewards.

Other Extras

Many cards also come with other valuable extras that can give them the edge over other credit cards. Some common extras that you should be looking for are purchase protection and zero fraud liability. Other useful benefits that can be helpful to certain consumers are purchase protection, auto rental collision damage waiver, and extended warranties. Depending on what you are looking to use the credit card for, these extra benefits can make a world of a difference and make the card a lot more useful to you. 

Conclusion

When looking at credit cards, it’s important first to figure out what type of card you need, whether it be a travel card, cash back, secured, and so on. Once you’ve narrowed down the list, the more obscure numbers are important to compare in order to truly figure out what card is most beneficial for your spending habits. Annual fees, interest rates, and other benefits can heavily differentiate two similar-looking credit cards.

featured stars
Featured Offers:

Chase Sapphire Preferred® Card

Chase Sapphire Preferred® Card

Serious Security

We encrypt data you share with us to ensure your experience is both easy and safe.

100% Free

BestCreditCard is completely free. Making the right financial decision shouldn’t cost you.
General Disclaimer
The card offers that appear on this site are from companies from which BestCreditCard receives compensation. This compensation may impact how and where products appear on this site (including, for example, the order in which they appear). BestCreditCard does not include all card companies or all card offers available in the marketplace.
Editorial Disclaimer
All content is written by editorial staff or writers engaged by the site, not by marketers/sales staff. Editors responsible for producing the content are not in contact or affiliated with any advertiser and are not compensated based on success of the affiliate links. All decisions regarding recommendations are determined separately from advertising relationships. Any opinions, analyses, reviews or recommendations expressed are those of the author's alone, and have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any card issuer.
Approval Odds
BestCreditCard calculates your approval odds by comparing your credit profile to other BestCreditCard members who were approved for this product. These approval odds are estimates only and do not guarantee approval. Credit card issuers use a variety of different types of credit scores and criteria to make credit decisions. The TransUnion credit score we provide is based on the VantageScore 3.0 model and may not be the credit scoring model used by financial institutions presenting offers on our website.